
It is ‘extremely unfair’ that seasonal workers on nine-month work permits have to pay into the Long-Term Care scheme, says a St Ouen farmer.
Christine Helio, of Manor Farm, said that people who came to the Island on such short-term arrangements would never benefit from the payments.
The Social Security Minister responded by saying that LTC payments were one part of ‘a commitment to society made by workers living in Jersey’.
Mrs Helio said: ‘They are on minimum wage, and it is extremely unfair. They will never get any benefit for the Long-Term Care scheme. It makes me very, very angry.’
She added: ‘They say it’s too difficult to make them exempt. The tax man is effectively stealing from these people. The scheme should be supported by those who actually live here. The maximum time that seasonal workers can be here is nine months. It just doesn’t make any sense.’
Senator Elaine Millar, the Minister for Social Security, said: ‘Seasonal workers make an important contribution to Jersey’s economy and community, and their payment of Long-Term Care charges forms part of this. LTC charges are one aspect of a commitment to society made by workers living in Jersey, whether seasonal or permanent.’
She added: ‘LTC charges are ring-fenced specifically to support long-term care and, as such, do not guarantee future entitlement. Support, like all other public services in Jersey, is provided according to need and eligibility, rather than an individual’s personal contribution.’
Mrs Helio was echoing concerns raised by the Jersey Farmers Union president Dougie Richardson at a recent scrutiny panel hearing.
He said that a seasonal farm worker could end up paying in excess of £650 in nine months.
‘This affects our seasonal workers unfairly as they will never benefit from this tax as they will not be living in Jersey permanently in later life,’ Bailiwick Express reported.
‘The union calculated that a seasonal farm worker earning £13.59 an hour and working an average of 49.5 hours a week currently pays about £393 in long-term care contributions over nine months,’ the newspaper reported. ‘Under the proposed increase, they said, that would rise to £655.88, or £72.87 a month.’
Mr Richardson was reported as saying that seasonal workers who earned £26,235 during their time in Jersey have their income tax deduction rate calculated using an equivalent annual salary of £35,000.
The number of seasonal workers has increased significantly in recent years to support key industries like hospitality, agriculture and fishing.
Most seasonal worker now come from India, the Philippines and Kenya, following a shift away from European countries in the wake of Brexit and as a result of better opportunities on the Continent, where wages have improved and living costs are lower.
Short-term seasonal permits are issued for a maximum of nine months, after which time people must leave for at least three months before they can return or reapply for another season. The policy was agreed to prevent people obtaining permanent residency status. Family members or dependants are not allowed to accompany or join seasonal workers. Permits are traditionally tied to a named employer, role, and specific accommodation (such as staff lodging or hostels).
Employers must provide equal pay, adhere to Jersey employment law and provide suitable accommodation. They are not allowed to deduct permit costs from wages. Workers are entitled to free emergency healthcare immediately and general healthcare after six months.
The people who do not need a work permit include British and Irish citizens, EU or EEA passport holders who have been granted settled or pre-settled status, Commonwealth citizens admitted on the grounds of UK ancestry, and ministers of religion.


